This was the first time I came to Great American Jewelry. My experience with Mary and Lauren was exceptional!

I was extremely happy with the personalized service I received.

I definitely recommend this company and will return if I have …

Larry was very friendly, honest and exhibited a professional manner. He made us very comfortable and easy to trust that he would do the right thing. We will definitely do business with him again.

Larry and his crew were wonderful. I had a great experience from start to finish. They were very patient, extremely knowledgeable, and friendly. We left with exactly what we were looking for, and I wouldn't hesitate to recommend them to …

I came across some old broken chains , earrings etc in my belongings so I called Great American Jewelry & got Mary in the phone. Being I had no idea what to do Mary gracefully explained the whole process to me .I came into the shop & am so …

Great American Jewelry is my go to shop with a beautiful selection of jewelry. The owner and staff are extremely knowledgeable and I highly recommend this business for your next purchase.

Pleasurable

I had the pleasure today to go to Great American Jewelry Store in My home town of Massapequa , NY.

The owners and the staff are more than gracious . I went in today and sold some old jewelry pieces I have not worn in years. They were Honest…

Working with Mary, Larry, and Laurie from Great American Jewelry was a terrific experience. My wife asked me to sell some of her unused jewelry and Great American has served my neighborhood for many years. They were extremely friendly, …

It was a real pleasure meeting you at your store. I found you to be honest, pleasant , funny and very knowledgable.

Wonderful stress-free experience with Larry at Great American Jewelry! All the employees are so sweet, friendly and helpful. Larry was so considerate and thoughtful – he truly took his time and was so kind. I was stressed walking in, and …

Larry very helpful and knowledgeable. customers.always come first. highly recommend them for jewelry purchases

Very friendly and professional!!

Great jewelry store! Larry looked at a bracelet I wanted to sell because I never gave it to my friend and it was purchased last year but still had the store tags attached but said it could only be returned within 30 days. Larry informed me…

Very pleasant experience, fair and quick. Laurie was very Friendly and helpful!

I would recommend them .

wonderful staff, very helpful offering guidance on redesigning heirloom jewelry. I am so happy with the results! Have sold gold here and believe it to be very competitively priced. Couldn't be happier! been using Great American Jewelry for …

Wonderful. Quick service, very professional and honest.

Great experience they were able to remove my ring safely. Staff was very friendly and helpful. Thank you so much!

Amazing experience. The staff was friendly, helpful and patient!! We will be coming back.

Went in to sell jewelry that I no longer wanted. Worked with Laurie and she was exceptional. She explained the whole process and it was all done in front of me. She answered any questions that I had, including about some jewelry that I wasn…

Amazing Service

Amazing work! Brought in my mishapped wedding band with missing diamonds and was fixed up so nice. Have purchased jewelry there for my daughter as well. Also got her ears pierced at 7 months there and they were so kind and patient. Great …

I went into this store to buy earrings. Amazing quality products and great customer service. Thanks Jacob and Larry!

Went in to buy a silver chain with cross. Jacob and Larry were a great help and very friendly. Great service

Great American Jewelry is a great family jewelry store. They have fantastic pieces, great prices, honest and knowledgeable people, as well as a way to fix jewelry, appraise it, and there is something for everyone.

I had a fantastic experience working with Larry on my diamond eternity band. From start to finish, he was incredibly communicative, honest, and transparent. His expertise and guidance made the process smooth and stress-free. The final piece…

Great American Jewelry was so so helpful throughout my process of buying a ring and their customer service was excellent. Janet was such a joy to work with and worked so hard to find me a diamond that fit my needs and most importantly for a…

"5/5 stars. My boyfriend recently purchased a beautiful diamond bracelet from Great American Jewelry. The staff was extremely knowledgeable and friendly, helping us find the perfect piece. The store's ambiance was elegant and clean, with a…

I ONLY trust my Jewlery to Great American Jewlery, Larry, Laurie and the rest of the staff are amazing. My ring was sized while I waited and they cleaned it too. Always going the extra mile.

Nicest and friendliest staff. Super helpful! Would highly recommend

Larry the owner and his wife Laurie are the nicest people to do business with. Besides having beautiful jewelry to sell, they also buy your family jewelry for the purpose of reselling, not just scrapping.

My favorite jewelry store.

Came in to adjust my watch and Great American Jewelry helped me asap with such friendly service! Highly recommend to anyone!

Larry and the team at Great American Jewelry were a pleasure to work with. Very knowledgeable and took the time to clearly explain everything. They helped me get what I needed and I left far more knowledgeable on the diamond industry. …

Maria and Larry were very generous with their time and explained the entire process. They took over two hours assessing the value of my items with no financial commitment whatsoever. I would highly recommend Great American Jewelry if you …

I sold a gold coin to Great American Jewellery, Larry and Mary were a huge help and made the process smooth and pleasant. Would definitely go to them again!

They made me a beautiful custom pendant that I was able to design with the help of Mary. It was a gift to myself for my birthday and even with the short timeframe they got it done right on time for me to have it on my birthday. They’ve …

Larry was excellent ,friendly, and a pleasure to work with. See him for all your jewelry needs and questions.

Got my first ear piercing here. Very nice and easy. Customer Service is amazing. Would very much recommend

Very friendly staff a pleasure to shop there

Highly reccomend im

I went in on a Sunday because my local gold buyer is closed on Sundays and had a fantastic experience with Larry and his staff they are all super friendly and safe environment over there, im looking forward to using them much more !!!

The best jewelry store on Long Island is Great American Jewelry in Massapequa. The staff is so helpful, friendly, and knowledgeable. If you have been hesitant to go to a jeweler and sell your old gold because you don't trust them, please …

Warm and friendly atmosphere. Great selections of jewelry They carefully listen to your request and determined to meet your needs. They are very knowledgeable about their product lines. I highly recommend them.

Very nice people and most of all honest people I would recommend anyone to this jewelry store.

The absolute best in the business! I’ve purchased so many different kinds of jewelry here and my last purchase was an engagement ring and my god what an experience from start to finish. Staff is super friendly and personable they sat down …

what a wonderful experience at this jewelry store , mary and janet were so helpful, informative and made me feel like i was family, when we finished i left a extremely satisfied customer. ( Shop Local and support) joe and loretta

Very nice and pleasant to deal with .

The staff was extremely helpful. They went above and beyond to accommodate me.

Linda the salesperson and Jorge the jeweler magician took our dream and made it a reality

I purchased a beautiful ring from Great American Jewelry. It was a great experience. They have a very friendly and helpful staff. I would recommend them to everyone. I'm only allowed to give them 5 stars but they deserve 10.

Today was my very first experience with Great American Jewelry, but it definitely won’t be my last. I worked with Mary, who couldn’t have been nicer or more professional, and I also met Larry, the owner, who was wonderful. They helped me …

I had showed them a picture of what i want. They custom hand made it. I knewnit was gonna be awsome! It came out sooo beautiful. I was over whelmed. Simply beautiful! Thank you to the whole staff for bringing it to life me! Love it and them…

Amazing experience! I bought my engagement ring from Great American, and the lovely couple who own the store were over the top helpful, willing to work within your price ranges, and customized the perfect ring. I can’t imagine going …

Everyone in the store was very professional and friendly. Especially the owner Larry. He worked with my mother and I until we were highly satisfied with what we wanted.

I do feel that I was given a fair price for the gold I was selling,very nice people and a pleasure to deal with.

Very nice people who provide wonderful service and expert workmanship. Easy to work with making a custom design that was perfect!!

The gentleman who was helping me was so Personable and welcoming. He took his time to explain the jewelry I was selling. His years of experience and honesty was so comforting. He went above and beyond the sale, by showing personal interest …

Larry was thorough when determining what my gold jewelry was worth. Will definitely sell to them again.

Mary and Janet are the absolute best. I recently got engaged and was having difficulty finding the inscription on my diamond as we purchased it from a private jeweler. I had several jewelers tell my fiance and I that the main stone does not…

If you are looking to sell high quality jewelry, this is the best place to go. My Dad and I went to about 12 jewelers on LI and 4 were very close to each other. We ended up choosing Larry and Lori because they were so professional, friendly…

Laurie, Larry, and the staff at Great American are awesome. They are professional honest and incredibly friendly. I had some gold to sell, and got the best price, and will be going back again.

It was great working with Larry and Lori on my engagement ring and wedding band. They helped me work through every detail and sourced a beautiful diamond for me. It was really great working with them. I am so pleased with my ring and the …

I went to Great American Jewelry with my marquis engagement ring that I've had since 1986 wanting to have the diamond put in a new 14k gold setting. I'm thrilled with the end result, Janet was sooooo helpful, I showed her a photo of an idea…

Outstanding!!!! My family and I had been going to a jeweler for years that my grandma went to. We’d drive 45 minutes to get there because you want a jeweler you can trust. Recently, this jeweler we always went to retired, and I recently …

Mary and Larry were so great and helpful! I went it for one thing and ended up asking them to help me fix my engagement ring. It was fixed right on the spot and beautifully. I will definitely be back!

I got my engagement ring from them a few years ago, and just recently had my mother's engagement ring turned into a necklace. They're wonderful to work with and I highly recommend them! Thank you for the great service and beautiful work.

Wonderful experience. Friendly atmosphere. Can't say enough goid things. I will be back.

Always great service. Everyone is very friendly and knowledgeable.

Mary and Lenny were excellent to sell gold and silver jewelry to.Were fair,kind and very professional.Made it easy.

Extremely nice owners and so very helpful and accommodating!!! Highly recommend

Had a few silver coins and salvage gold Jewelry, offered a very fair price with no haggling. Tested gold in front of me to separate different grades. Definitely will do business with, again.

Great experience with a great team!

The staff is very professional, helpful, & friendly.

All nice folks here. All are seasoned experienced people in all aspects of the selling and buying of jewelry experience.

i highly recommend this store and people for any of your needs

Very kind and friendly staff, very helpful in buying an estate piece from me and assessing a watch. Gave us a great price! Thank you!

My Family has used Great American Jewelry for years. Each employee makes you feel welcome and helps choose the perfect piece ! Big shout out to Janet who helped with our engagement ring and wedding bands . She took her time to make sure we…

This was such an amazing experience. Everyone was extremely friendly and helpful. I was very pleased with the service, and it far exceeded my expectations.

I had an excellent visit there the owner had a great talk he was very kind great experience

Staff is beyond amazing and catered to my exact needs best jeweler on the Island they resized a ring for me same day 100% will be going back

Really nice, fair people.

I was highly recommended to Great American Jewelry by a friend and am so happy I have found them! I needed a college graduation gift for my daughter and was also getting a 30th wedding anniversary gift for myself. Janet was so patient with …

I brought in a diamond to be made into a necklace for my daughter. These people are very pleasant and do beautiful work. My daughter was thrilled and gets compliments every time she wears it. My thanks to Mary and the rest of the staff.

5 stars for Great American Jewelry. Mary was great . Great customer service . For a first time customer I felt very comfortable purchasing an engagement ring for my future wife . Great American Jewelry a special place to purchase for …

I’ve recently used Great American Jewelry to resize one of my rings, which was a difficult thing to do because of the knuckle on my finger! The jeweler worked and worked until he got it to fit perfectly! The ring was a family heirloom and …

Friendly service and fair prices. Animal lovers!!! Well worth it with gold at all time high. Ace Hardware shopping center.

Mary,Janet and Larry were absolutely amazing took very good care of me I got more than I thought thank you all I highly recommend them

Hands down the best place for an engagement ring. I wanted a 10/10 ring and they gave me a 100/10. Mary and Larry are amazing people and I’m glad I came to them for help. Anything u need they can provide. Everyone there makes u feel …

I highly recommend this jewelry store. The staff were attentive and helpful. They took their time with me and answered all of my questions. No pressure at all. They have a great selection and a large variety of beautiful jewelry for any …

I recently had the pleasure of doing business with Great American Jewelry for my engagement ring purchase. Laurie and Larry and the rest of the team had remarkable depth and knowledge about engagement rings and diamonds. They patiently …

My partner of 19 years and I went to Great American Jewelry to pick out our wedding rings. We have an absolutely lovely experience with Mary for she took her time in showing us wedding rings with no pressure and answered all of our …

I took on a gold signet ring that I have owned since the 1970s which no longer fits my finger. Within five minutes I was offered a reasonable price for it and left with a check. A great experience !

Laurie and the entire staff are the best in the business! They make you feel like family and always do the right thing. Simply the BEST!!

Our experience today was seamless and while focusing on the sale the staff (owner) shared so many stories that we felt so comfortable thru the process. They are trustworthy and a pleasure to work with.

Great American Jewelry is an exceptional place to sell your precious gold pieces. Their service is top-notch, and they offered me top dollar for my items. I couldn't be happier with the experience. I would highly recommend Great American …

Great experience picking out and buying our engagement ring! The staff was very knowledgeable and helpful throughout this process! I highly recommend this jeweler!

I was helped by Janet and she was so lovely! She was so helpful and friendly! I would recommend if you have any jewelry needs to come here!

We absolutely love coming here. My fiancé started going to Janet for all new jewelry needs early into our relationship, and later knew she was the right choice to help design an engagement ring utilizing the center stone from his mother’s …

My wife and I discovered this place when we first moved to massapequa two years ago, and we refuse to go anywhere else! Larry and the whole team are phenomenal! When it comes down to the jewelry, they have the best quality, style and the …

First time shopping here. Nice place with friendly staff and decent selection and prices. Debbie was very helpful in helping me find the perfect birthday gift for my wife (which she loved) Definitely recommend and will be back for future …

Great American Jewelry is the epitome of excellence. They go above and beyond to ensure satisfaction. They really listen to their clients, and take great care in details. I would recommend Great American Jewelry to anyone. I had an …

Went in today to Great American and I am not at all jewelry savvy. Mary explained everything to me as we went along and was very polite. I felt like I knew her for a long time. I have to admit I was quite skeptical this morning before going…